Pope Benedict retires to the apartment in Castel Gandolfo after appearing for the last time.

CNS PHOTO | L'OSSERVATORE ROMANO VIA CATHOLIC PRESS PHOTO

Pope Benedict retires to the apartment in Castel Gandolfo after appearing for the last time.

March 11, 2013
FRANCIS ROCCA
CATHOLIC NEWS SERVICE

The period immediately following a pontificate is one of excited speculation, more or less loose, about the identity of the next pope.

Though secrecy rules do not forbid cardinals from naming their preferences, custom and prudence effectively do. In any case, as history shows, once the electors get behind locked doors, their deliberations take on a dynamic impossible to forecast or affect from outside.

Such uncertainty makes a journalist's job hard in one sense and easy in another, since practically any outcome is at least marginally plausible. That is especially the case in the wake of an event – Pope Benedict XVI's resignation – which a few weeks ago most observers would have dismissed as far-fetched.

For members of the Church, the interregnum is inevitably a time of suspense and even anxiety. A fear that the conclave might not choose the right man does not necessarily reflect a lack of faith. In 1997, then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger told an interviewer that the Holy Spirit does not "dictate the candidate for whom one must vote."

"Probably the only assurance he offers is that the thing cannot be totally ruined," the future Pope Benedict said. "There are too many contrary instances of popes the Holy Spirit obviously would not have picked."

The almost unprecedented way in which Pope Benedict brought his own pontificate to an end has increased apprehension among some.

In Italy and elsewhere, observers have suggested that his resignation was precipitated by the Vatican's internal problems - if not the rumoured wars among bureaucratic factions, then the corruption and mismanagement sensationally documented in the 2012 "VatiLeaks" of confidential correspondence.

In this view, the former pope is not the only one who needs replacing.

Even if Pope Benedict had not left behind a Vatican surrounded by such controversies, his way of leaving was bound to create disquiet.

"One pope dies, you make another," runs an Italian proverb, with the reassuring message that life goes on.

But this time, the fact that life goes on makes things more complicated. The historic anomaly of a living former pope presents no theological or canonical difficulties for the Church, but it will require an emotional adjustment from many of the faithful.

Pope Benedict has recognized that his resignation is unlike that of any other leader departing the scene.

CONFUSING ASSURANCES

In the last two days of his pontificate, he pledged obedience to his successor and noted that he was leaving the "active exercise of the (Petrine) ministry." He also said he was "not returning to private life" but would belong "always and totally to everyone, to the whole church" and "remain, so to speak, within St. Peter's precincts."

Many will find these assurances both consoling and mysterious.

Catholics, whose ecclesiology calls for a pope to help preserve their unity, are in a sense orphans during a papal interregnum. And this time they have had no cathartic process of mourning and burial to help purify the complex emotions children feel upon losing a parent.

The Vatican has not said whether Pope Benedict, despite his promise to remain "hidden" in retirement, will take part in his successor's Mass of installation. Were he to do so, it might add a new dimension to that liturgy – a symbolic passing of the keys - which might make the papal transition feel more complete.

Otherwise, until Pope Benedict's funeral Mass the closest thing to ritual closure of the last pontificate will remain a moment shortly after 8 p.m. Feb. 28, when Swiss Guards at Castel Gandolfo slowly shut a pair of massive wood doors.