Cardinal-designate Gerhard-Muller

Cardinal-designate Gerhard-Muller

February 3, 2014
FRANCIS ROCCA
CATHOLIC NEWS SERVICE

Violence is the "greatest corruption of religion," while belief in a single God is the "principle and source of love between human beings," says a new study by a Vatican advisory panel of theologians.

God, the Trinity, and the Unity of Humanity was released Jan. 16 by the International Theological Commission, a papal-appointed group advising the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

The document argued against the idea that monotheism inevitably gives rise to religiously inspired violence.

The 55-page document was prepared by a 10-member subcommittee that included Archbishop Savio Hon Tai-Fai, secretary of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples.

It was approved by Cardinal-designate Gerhard Muller, head of the doctrinal congregation.

A rendition of the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah. The Old Testament includes a number of instances of violence 'that involve God directly or indirectly,' say the theologians.

A rendition of the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah. The Old Testament includes a number of instances of violence 'that involve God directly or indirectly,' say the theologians.

The document responds to arguments positing "an intrinsic link between monotheism and violence." It says such arguments reflect a "number of misunderstandings" of "authentic Christian thought about the one God."

The very category of monotheism is "too generic," the authors argue, since it does not distinguish among the different traditions of Judaism, Islam and Christianity.

The document also objects to what it calls a "cultural simplification that reduces the alternatives to a choice between a necessarily violent monotheism and a presumptively tolerant polytheism."

The Bible contains a number of instances of "violence that involve God directly or indirectly," the authors acknowledge.

Examples include God's destruction of the world in the great flood, and of Sodom and Gomorrah by fire, as well as several occasions when God orders the Israelites to exterminate armies or conquere cities as sacrifices to him.

While it rejects any interpretations that oppose a "bad God of the Old Testament and a good God of the New Testament," the document notes that the Hebrew Scriptures were written for a tribal culture.

That culture was "profoundly intertwined with the ethos – intolerably violent for us – of an archaic-sacral conception of honour and sacrifice, of conflict and reprisal, of war and conquest."

EVOLVING ATTITUDES

Moreover, the authors argue, the contrasting portrayals of violence in the Scriptures demonstrate the historical evolution of attitudes toward violence, "with the prospect of progressively overcoming it" through faith in God.

"The event of Jesus Christ, which universally manifests the love of God, enables the religious justification of violence to be neutralized," they argue.

"The death and resurrection of Christ (are) the key to the reconciliation of human beings."

The authors draw a link between Trinitarian love and the harmony of society: Through the sacraments, men and women become children of God and brothers and sisters to each other, achieving a spiritual unity that promotes a "human culture of social ties and the overcoming of enmity among peoples."

ECONOMIC, POLITICAL INTERESTS

Violence that appears religiously inspired is often really driven by economic and political interests that exploit faith and tend to malign religion in the name of a false humanism, the document argues.

Yet the authors warn that religion is constantly in need of purification, lest it yield to the "temptation of trading divine might for temporal power, which in the end takes the road of violence."

The document is currently only available in Italian, along with an introduction in English and other languages, at the website of the Jesuit magazine La Civilta Cattolica.